Kelly Clarkson Sings Her Hits on ‘Ellen’
By Joseph Oliveto
Kelly Clarkson’s decline in popularity is proof-positive that emerging as the winning contestant on “American Idol” does not guarantee that one will go on to have a tremendously succesful recording career. She was fairly popular for a while there, but was quickly replaced by more talented and interesting pop stars like Katy Perry and Lady Gaga.
(In this particular genre, the terms “talented” and “interesting” are relative.)
However, according to AOL Music, Clarkson did manage to remind the country that she exists when she performed on “The Ellen Degeneres Show,” yesterday, March 6.
With a fifth studio album on the way, Clarkson performed old hits like “Miss Independent” and “Since U Been Gone.” As big as those songs were when they were first released–it was impossible to walk through the mall without hearing one of them about a dozen times–a lot of us have forgotten about them by this point. But who says it’s too early for nostalgia?
We’re not exactly excited for any new work from Clarkson; she didn’t push any musical boundaries before and there is no reason to expect that she will in the future. While recent “Idol” contestants like Crystal Bowersox have forged unique musical identities of their own, acts like Clarkson give us more of the disposable pop that is clogging the airwaves.
Kelly, since you’ve been gone, well we can kind of breathe. Keep it that way, dear?
Are you excited for a new Kelly Clarkson album?
Thursday, April 7, 2011 11:51AM
Mr. Oliveto, where do you come up with this "decline in popularity " you speak of? Kelly Clarkson is one of the biggest performers and artists in music today. Her last album was a giant hit and still gets lots of airplay almost two years after it's release.
I guarentee you when her next album comes out this fall you'll see an all out blitz of Kelly due to her large legion of fans and the knowledge that she is the best singer out there today. Christina is the only one who can stand along side of her, Beyonce is so over-rated it makes one puke. Kelly is a true artist/songwriter and proves herself everytime she takes the stage.
As for you ignorant "disposable pop" tag you hang on her, it only proves you did not listen to the brilliant "My December" album that pissed off Clive and her record company. It was anything put disposable pop and showed her worth as a songwriter. You sound like a very uniformed third rate critic.
Thursday, April 7, 2011 12:35PM
This guy clearly knows nothing about artistry or superior vocals. Maybe he should cover auto racing?
Thursday, April 7, 2011 1:20PM
Joseph,
Kelly didn't push musical boundaries before? Are you kidding? Clive Davis begged her to go more mainstream on her third album, but she refused… she had a vision for the album, and she didn't care if it wasn't bubble-gum pop, a la Perry.
Lady Gaga? She *depends* on image. If our standard for *music* is *image* and choreography, then you're right. But I'll stick with the singer's ability to actually *sing*.
Finally, Kelly doesn't have to remind the country that she still exists… you may not be familiar with the genre known as country, but Kelly's duet with Jason Aldean was #1 in country and has been hanging out in the top 10 for sometime.
People who actually know something about the ability to sing recognize Kelly's talent. You enjoy the flavor of the month… I'll stick with an amazing vocalist.
Thursday, April 7, 2011 4:34PM
When she separates from her record label (and she will), I guarantee there will be a resurgence for her in both respect and popularity. It's her label that brings her down, IMO. She has one of the greatest female voices of all time, and any true fan knows that she is leagues better than what her singles let on. She has a true, deep connection to great music but the general public has no knowledge of that.
Thursday, April 7, 2011 5:40PM
The writer of this article was unnecessarily cruel, insulting kelly clarkson. WE DO NOT NEED YOUR OPINION ON HOW MUCH YOU HATE HER. OK? kelly clarkson was named the most successful american idol of ALL TIME. get your facts right before bashing on her.
Thursday, April 7, 2011 8:42PM
Are you kidding me with this trash you wrote? You actually call the crap that Katty Perry does more interesting? Talk about disposable POP! Clarkson has one of the best voices in the industry today. Have you even listened to songs like "Sober" "I'm Ready Now" "You still won't know what its like"
You may not be looking forward to her new album, but your one of the few.
Thursday, April 7, 2011 8:51PM
I'm sorry but the author of this article is a d-bag. You're wrong Kelly is here to stay, she has been in this industry for almost nine years so. And just wait when her new album comes out because you would wish that wouldn't have said what you said now. Besides Simon Cowell has said that she will have a long career and the man knows his stuff, more than you, some stupid blogger who has nothing better to do and just be mean and hurtful. Kelly had no problem going against Gaga, Katy Perry she did it with "All I Ever Wanted" so she can do it again. And who knows, when her album comes out Katy's "Teenage Dream" era will be dying out.
Thursday, April 7, 2011 9:02PM
What the heck is wrong with you? Kelly Clarkson is a worldwide superstar. Her music is amazing and still relevant. She has a better voice than Katy Perry and Lady GaGa. She can sing anything and everything. She has had plenty of hits and most recently a #1 song on the Billboard Country Chart with Jason Aldean. There are plenty of people, including myself, waiting for her new album. Her voice is amazing. You have no idea what you are talking about. Sorry you feel Ms. Clarkson isnt flashy and runs around naked like the other singers you mentioned. Go get a clue!!!
Thursday, April 7, 2011 9:05PM
Coward. I guess you are not going to post it. I just wanted to tell you that you are a hack. How dare you talk about one of the greatest voices of all time like that. Go get a real job.
Thursday, April 7, 2011 9:05PM
Your an idiot.
Thursday, April 7, 2011 9:34PM
Wow, Joseph. That bitter pill you swallowed seems to be working. Kelly Clarkson is a kick-ass talent, regardless of how much you would like to convince us otherwise. Enjoy eating your words come September.
Thursday, April 7, 2011 10:13PM
hahahahahahahahahah Kelly Clarkson's decline in popularity lol??????????????????????? Did you actually go there???????????????????? Also to say she has been replaced by gaga and katy perry. omg lol lol lol lol uhhhhhhhh you clearly don't know what you are talking about. What an idiotic JERK. I wouldn't think on an article like this, you would get to be that opinionated. I need a job in this then. I could do lot better than this, thats for sure. I don't lie. JERK.
"Kelly, since you’ve been gone, well we can kind of breathe. Keep it that way, dear?"- wow is all I can say. immature.
Thursday, April 7, 2011 10:36PM
I almost feel sorry for this guy's lack of musical knowledge… Calling Kelly Clarkson disposable pop garbage yet praising Katy Perry? Even ignoring the fact that Kelly can sing circles around Katy Perry and Lady Gaga, Katy Perry's sound is almost identical to Kelly's most mainstream pop songs. She worked with Kelly's producers (Max/Luke). Do your research dude.
And Since U Been Gone after almost 7 years is still getting more radio airplay than I Kissed a Girl and Just Dance.
Thursday, April 7, 2011 11:18PM
I found your article in my alerts and couldn't believe it was written by a well informed music critic and I was right. Kelly has been out of the public eye for a good part of the last year and not because she is no longer relevant as you alluded too. It's because she's been hard at work on her 5th album. She is not one to pose half naked in magazines in order to stay in the public's eye or as you say remain relevant.
She is still the highest selling idol worldwide and I bet you when her next album comes out in September, it will not only hit number one on the Billboard charts, but will outsell "relevant" artists such as Katy Perry and Britney's new release.
In the meantime, she has a number one hit on the country charts with her duet with Jason Aldean. Also Ellen once again invited her to be the featured performer on her yearly taped show in Orlando amusement park which Kelly received rave reviews in all the news outlets. Try to be more informed next time before you do a job on one of the most respected artist in the business. If you don't believe me, just ask Reba, you do know who that is, don't you?
Friday, April 8, 2011 8:20AM
Was this a joke? Kelly's duet with Jason Eldean (I think it's him 'cuz I listen to hear her) out on country radio is phenomenal. She has a great voice and is way more likeable than Madonna, Gaga or Aguilera.
Friday, April 8, 2011 8:22AM
How dare you speak for all Kelly's fans by dissing her. Lady GaGa is a friggin joke. Kelly is the real thing. I couldn't wait to see her on Ellen, and she rocked the place. She has a wonderful voice. Keep your lousy opinions to yourself, because obviously you are tone deaf if you even put Katy Perry and Lady GagMe in the same category as a great artist. Shame on you.
Friday, April 8, 2011 8:22AM
what the hell is that all about.
She is the best IDOL ever – some of the ones after her were and still are terrible.
I look forward to her new album and am sure it will be full of hits!!!
Friday, April 8, 2011 8:23AM
Who the heck hired this clown?
Friday, April 8, 2011 8:24AM
Wait….so are we now equating outrageousness and pseudo originality to having more talent? I'm confused at this author kinda slamming down Kelly. Yes, she hasn't been as public these past few years. She hasn't had a meltdown. She hasn't been caught in the tabloids. Where she is present is where it matters: radio and the general music scene. If you already forgot, she had some big hits with her last album (My Life Would Suck Without You and Already Gone, anyone?). And sorry but Katy and Gaga have been around since, what, 2007-2008? It's impressive Kelly's career, when so many acts that came out during her time (2002) have now gone to be obscure.
Friday, April 8, 2011 8:25AM
Joseph Oliveto may be able to write but he clearly doesn't know anything about good music or good artists. I honestly think he wrote this article to cause drama and get readers to visit this page to register and so he can get advertising credits. I hope you got what you were looking for, asshole!!!
Friday, April 8, 2011 8:25AM
Forgot to mention she is number one on the country charts right now! Really, Katy Perry?? Perry can't sing without her vocals being synthesized.
Anybody that has to where a meat dress to an awards show seems to me to be the desperate one…..
Friday, April 8, 2011 8:25AM
This article is ridiculous nonsense. Sounds to me like the writer is a a failed entertainer, perhaps?
Friday, April 8, 2011 8:26AM
Last i Heard she has at hit duet on top of the country charts,how does that = a decline in popularity.
Friday, April 8, 2011 8:27AM
And by stirring up the waters like this, you have just created another resurgence of her popularity! Thank you for that!
The fact that you think she is even worthy of commenting on says she is relevant!
I think she is talented and brings a great energy to her music.
Friday, April 8, 2011 8:27AM
I totally agree with you and this guy isn't worthy of having his story in print–Wow what an idiot
Friday, April 8, 2011 8:30AM
I completely agree with your opinion RJD, I don't think that she has less talent. Oh, and the critic that wrote this…..you have no idea what real music or talent is. Have a great weekend.
Friday, April 8, 2011 8:31AM
RJD, I agree with you. This critique of Clarkson is really harsh and diva-ish! I was just listening to her last CD the other day. Sure, maybe her songs are a little dated, but I still have to listen to the Beatles music over and over again in the mall too! The only reason Mr. Oliveto is saying these things is because he has fed into the politics between Clarkson and her former producer. Even on her worst day, Kelly Clarkson still sings better than some little high school twit whose lyrics about riding the school bus is silly-stupid, yet who has managed to make it on the pop charts. Even on her best day, Clarkson has a true vocal range that can hold her own against many rock greats, past and present. Go take some Midol, Mr. Oliveto!
Friday, April 8, 2011 8:36AM
Seriously, how does a person with a #1 hit go to being a has-been? Does this donk even listen to music? Get a clue loser.
Friday, April 8, 2011 8:43AM
I totally agree with all of these people defending Kelly Clarkson who basically defined what "American Idol" was even all about. She rocked that show and more than helped make it what it is today. The whole country was thrilled for her and in love with her. She remained nice and true to herself and never became a "diva" or lost sight of her values. But aside from all of that, she is an amazing natural talent, much like those in the Glee cast. Her voice is fabulous and she just sings without any gimmicks or crazy outfits or crazy hair. If she is not as prominent in People Magazine or US as many of the other so called "stars" are, it is because she truly wants as normal a life as possible and she is doing what she wants to do, singing what she wants to sing and performing where she want to perform … instead of subjecting herself to the magazines' obsessions with weight, appearance and fashion. I read a quote from her not long ago where she more or less said, "I have everything I will ever need, I am set for life financially, I do not have to be pressured to compromise my values and talent."
Friday, April 8, 2011 8:48AM
Well Said!!!! ABSOLOUTLY AGREE! We weregiven a wonderful gift from God and we are truely blessed to have a singer/songwriter like Kelly! And being a fan of Katy Perry and Gaga, I still feel that Kelly brings much more to the table with her songwriting and especially her vocals. I have seen all in concert, and no one brings it like Kelly when it comes to vocals!!
Friday, April 8, 2011 9:02AM
Kelly is an awesome talented performer!!! How can you compare her to no talent Katy Perry or Lady Gagme?
Friday, April 8, 2011 9:02PM
Clean out your ears and take a writing class! You obviously don't recognize quality music when you hear it. Kelly Clarkson is one of the best vocalists of our time, she can sing circles around Gaga or Katy Perry. I'm guessing you don't know this because you've never bothered to see her perform live. Her duet with Jason Aldean is currently #1 on the CMT chart, so I'm not sure why you think she's "been gone" for a while. She's also a talented, ASCAP-award-winning song writer. Clearly, you whipped up this spiteful little piece without doing your homework. In fact, you couldn't even be bothered to post a current pic.
Reading your blog was a waste of my time. Do you seriously think you have what it takes to become a writer? I hope you have a back up plan…
Monday, April 11, 2011 5:58PM
Nancy, thanks for the kind words. I laughed when you mentioned the Beatles. I am a HUGE Beatles fan. I have lived and breathed their music all my life and I do listen to them often but I also like to listen to what's new out there and Kelly Clarkson is one of those people who pull you in with their raw voice and emotion.
I actually have her CDs in my car and listen to them all the time. I've never had someone's voice, expect maybe for Sinatra during his 1950's Capitol years, have such an effect on me. I think she's beautiful, sincere and doesn't take herself very seriously except when she gets into a studio. I also appreciate how she shuns the limelight. You never see her in People magazine or the Enquierer. Can't wait for her next album, I'm sure she won't dissapoint.
Friday, April 15, 2011 1:30PM
Where have you been Oliveto?? Read her fan sites, she has great friends i.e. Reba, Jordin Sparks ,Miranda Lambert to mention a few. Since her last tour Kelly was finishing the new album and was ready to go when DA's RCA waited to release it!! They have been the thorn in Kell'y career. She wants to branch out but they won't let her. Kelly is also VERY popular in England, Europe, Australia and all in-between. Do You Oliveto have any music connections.??
Kelly has one more album after the new one for RCA's contract . Then I hope she will land a new and relavent record company..?? maybe Reba's?? Go to youtube and see her vocal note ranges in her songs!!! &%#$$#